Saturday, July 10, 2010

OK, so like, I actually watched New Moon and it was totally awful!!

This past weekend I was unlucky enough to watch New Moon, the second movie in the Twilight saga. Though I went into this voluntarily and with EXTREMELY low expectations, I was somehow still surprised. How a movie this bad gets made and even worse, makes large sums of money is a question that may be beyond my ability to answer.
I had seen the first Twilight movie going into this and thought it was fairly terrible. New Moon takes everything that was awful about the first movie and magnifies it about a thousand times. Simply things like acting and decent dialog escape every scene. Everyone involved with this movie appears to have no acting ability to speak of, not a single one. And if they do, you would never know it because they are saddled with some all time bad source material. Can we stop pretending that high sales equals quality. This story sucks. These books are, at best, trashy KMart romance novels, minus the romance.

My real problem with Twilight goes beyond my love of good cinema. This "saga", though meant as entertainment, cannot escape having underlying messages, many of which are shockingly disturbing on many levels. Maybe it speaks to the lowering of society's standards, or perhaps parents just don't care anym
ore but, if I had a daughter there is no way I would let her anywhere near these books and movies.

The main character Isabella Swan, usually just shortened to Bella, is a high
school girl who falls in love with Edward Cullen, a 108 year old vampire masquerading as a 17 year old school mate of Bella's. Though Edward apparently wants to keep his distance from Bella, the two inevitably fall in "love". I put love in quotes because that's the best way to describe the plot but is so far from what is being depicted on screen that it's scary. If you step back from t
he characters and look at the situation in general terms this is what you get, a young vulnerable girl moves to a new town and begins a relationship with a much older man. Though he has reservations about her and their being together, he can't resist her. He is overbearing, saying things like, "I just like watching over you" and seemingly always around, constantly knowing where she is and who she is with. This behavior is depicted as romantic but in reality is a serious issue. Edward may appear to be a 17 year old but he has done over a century of living, despite the irony that he is already dead.

In New Moon, Edward feels that he can no longer be with Bella out of fear that he is putting her in danger. This sounds like the classic, it's not you, it's me. He had his fun with the younger girl and now he is throwing her aside. He disappears and will not return calls or letters. He leaves Bella abandoned and broken. She was already a textbook case of a female with serious self worth and self esteem issues, bordering on clinical depression. After Bella met Edward, she began to equate her self worth with her relationship with Edward. He was the source of all her happiness and when he left he took all of that with him.

Maybe because I'm not a girl I'm missing the point. Are we really trying to teach our young women that they should tie their happiness to a man and have their emotions taken command of by another person? Twilight's answer seems to be yes. I would also be remiss in pointing out that Twilight takes bad parenting to a whole new level.














"Wait, my daughter is in the forest again with a killer on the loose? As long
as she is home before dinner I guess that's fine."

Bella's father seems resigned to his inability to get his daughter to do the right things, he can't even keep her in the house when there are a series of murders in the forest near her house. Maybe you shouldn't be sheriff if you can't get people to follow the rules. Just a thought.

The big addition to New Moon is Jacob and his werewolf alter ego. Though he made an appearance in the first Twilight movie, he and his abs gained a much larger role in New Moon with the addition of some very helpful steroids. It's Jacob that creates the love triangle with Bella and Edward.

I would like to end with a brief comment on something I read in Entertainment Weekly. It was a review for Eclipse, the next chapter in this big steaming pile of a franchise. It ended, what was a very positive and slightly delusional review, with the thought that the reason Twilight is so popular with teenage girls is because, at it's core, it's about a woman wanting to be desired.
Let me get this right, the whole point of the whole Twilight universe is to awaken the selfish longing to be wanted in women of any age. How is this ok? A girl should put herself at considerable risk and danger, not to mention alienate her friends all so she can feel desired. Not only that, but when the source of the desire finally is done, she so needs to be desired that she abuses the trust of one of her close friends so that she won't have to truly deal with the emotional fallout.

Many people call Twilight a romance, and perhaps it needs to be technically classified there but, in reality, it is a thinly veiled fantasy of the author to simply be wanted at all costs. We should recognize it for what it is, a narcissistic fantasy that we should steer all young girls away from.

No comments:

Post a Comment